Expertie Guidelines for Reporting and Removing Content
Updated
Every review, piece of advice, poll answer and college response on Expertie has a “Report” link next to it. Anyone can use it to tell us that something is wrong or offensive, and a member of our team looks at every report. Expertie exists so that students, alumni and parents can share what a college is really like and read about the experiences of others. To write a review you need an Expertie account with a verified email address, and every review is read by a member of our team before it appears on the site. We do not edit what you write, and we do not filter out or remove reviews because they are negative. We are not the judge of who is right when a reviewer and a college disagree about the facts. We remove content only when it breaks these guidelines or our Terms of Use. We apply the same standards to every college, whether or not it works with Expertie or has claimed its profile – that is how we keep the reviews trustworthy.
The following include the circumstances in which we will consider removing a review:
- AI Generated Content: A review must describe your own first-hand experience, in your own words. A review written, drafted or largely rewritten by AI software or a chatbot is removed. Using a tool only to fix spelling or grammar is fine.
- Coerced Users: There is clear evidence that someone else – a college, a coaching centre, an agent or anyone else – told the reviewer what to write or what rating to give, or offered something in return for the review.
- Inappropriate Content: The review uses abusive or offensive language, including slurs or insults about caste, religion, region, language, gender, sexuality, disability or appearance, in any language.
- Personal Information: The review shares personal details of anyone, including the reviewer – for example a name, phone number, email address, roll number, Aadhaar number or date of birth.
- Criticism of Individuals: The review criticises a person by name, or describes them so closely (for example “the HOD of the second-year batch”) that they can be identified.
- Specific Crimes: The review accuses someone of a specific crime or offence. Expertie is not the place to report a crime – please go to the police or the right authority. General statements such as “ragging is a problem in the hostels” are not a specific crime and are allowed.
- Threats of Harm: The review contains a threat of harm to the reviewer or to anyone else.
- Nonsensical Content: The review cannot be understood – for example random letters, a poem or song lyrics.
- Third-Party Links: The review contains links to other websites, apps or social media pages.
- Clear Inaccuracy: The review is about a different college, or contains something that is plainly and provably false – for example it describes hostel life in Pune when the college is in Chennai. We do not decide disputes about opinions or experiences.
- Uninformed Reviewer: The reviewer says they do not know the college, or has no recent first-hand experience of it as a student, alum or parent.
- Q: How would you rate your overall experience? A: I don’t know… / Pata nahi…
- Intellectual Property: The review copies someone else’s writing or other material protected by copyright or trademark.
- Advertising Content: The review advertises or promotes something – a coaching centre, an admission agent, a course, a product or another college.
We expect everyone on Expertie to treat each other with respect. Disagreement and honest criticism are welcome; personal attacks, deliberate provocation and unproven accusations of wrongdoing are not. Content that attacks anyone for their caste, religion, region, language or gender is never allowed. You can describe a bad experience, as long as you describe it respectfully.
College Responses
A college that has claimed its Expertie profile, and for which our team has switched responses on, may publish one response to a review. Each response is labelled with the college’s name and the date it was published, and it represents the views of the college, not of Expertie. Whether a college responds, claims its profile or works with Expertie in any way never changes whether a review is shown, its rating or how we check it. Reviews stay subject to these guidelines whether or not a college has responded, and we may remove a review that breaks them at any time, including after a response. We do not edit college responses, and we stay neutral when a college and a reviewer disagree about the facts.
A response must be written by a person authorised by the college, and it must be professional and polite, even when the college disagrees with the review. Responses are subject to these guidelines and to our Terms of Use.
The following include the circumstances in which we will consider removing a college response:
- AI Generated Content: The response was written, drafted or largely rewritten by AI software or a chatbot. Using a tool only to fix spelling or grammar is fine.
- Personal Information: The response shares personal details of anyone – for example a name, age, marks, attendance, discipline, health or admission status – even if the reviewer shared them first.
- Identifying Individuals: The response names a student, parent, staff member, reviewer or anyone else, or describes them so closely that they can be identified.
- Questioning the Reviewer: The response questions who the reviewer is, whether they study at the college, their age, their motives or whether the review is genuine. A college that thinks a review breaks these guidelines should use the “Report” link – we judge it by the same standards as any other report.
- Threats or Pressure: The response threatens, intimidates or retaliates against the reviewer, or asks the reviewer – or offers them anything – to change or remove the review.
- Inappropriate Content: The response uses abusive or offensive language, or demeans any person or group.
- Accusations Against Individuals: The response accuses an identifiable person of dishonesty, misconduct or a crime.
- Clear Inaccuracy: The response contains something that is plainly and provably false – for example a wrong claim about the college’s approval, affiliation, accreditation, rankings or awards.
- Off-Topic Content: The response does not answer the review, or brings in unrelated complaints or political comment.
- Advertising Content: The response advertises or promotes something – for example admission offers, fee discounts or events.
- Third-Party Links and Contact Information: The response contains links to other websites, email addresses or phone numbers.
- Nonsensical Content: The response cannot be understood.
A college should not respond publicly to a review that describes a specific threat of harm, a specific person at risk or a specific incident of abuse or ragging, and we may switch responses off for such a review. A college may respond to general comments about safety or student well-being, as long as the response does not refer to any particular student or incident.
Responses that break these guidelines may be removed, and a college that breaks them repeatedly may lose the ability to respond.
Like everything people post on Expertie, every college response has a “Report” link that anyone can use to tell us it breaks these guidelines.
Additional Information
You must be 18 or older to write a review or answer our survey. You may write in English, Hindi or a mix of the two.
What we publish about you: only who you are to the college (for example “Second year”, “Alum” or “Parent”) and the date. We never publish your name, email address or anything else that identifies you. You can download everything Expertie holds about you, or delete it, from your account at any time; deleting your account deletes your reviews, advice and survey answers – they are not kept anonymously. See our Privacy Policy and our DPDP compliance page for your rights under the Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023.
For more on how we check what people send us, see our Quality Control procedures.
If you think we got a decision about your content or your report wrong, write to our Grievance Officer – see Grievance Redressal.
See our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy for more information. Terms used here have the meaning given in our Terms of Use, unless this page says otherwise.
We may change, add to or remove any part of these guidelines at any time. The version on this page is the one we apply.
Quality Control for User-Submitted Content
We use several checks on the reviews, advice and survey answers people send us. No check can prove that one review is accurate, so ours aim to do two things: 1) catch content that is mistaken, fake or breaks these guidelines before it is published, and 2) make sure that what we show for a college reflects the people who actually wrote about it.
Submission of User Content
People share their experiences on Expertie through our college and major surveys, which you can reach from “Write a review” at the top of every page and from links across the site. To submit anything you need an Expertie account and a verified email address, and you must confirm that you are 18 or older. We do not ask for a college email address, because not every college gives its students one, and because we want alumni – who often no longer use their college email – to be able to review their college too.
Quality Control Procedures
We have three main stages of quality control for the reviews, advice and survey answers people send us.
- Automatic checks
Every review is checked automatically when it is sent, for links, email addresses and phone numbers, answers such as “I don’t know”, random letters, text written all in capitals and text that has already been posted. These checks never publish or remove anything on their own: they point our team to what needs a closer look. - Review by our team, and your reports
A member of our team reads every review before it is published. After that, anyone can use the “Report” link to tell us about content that breaks these guidelines, and a member of our team reviews every report. If reported content breaks the guidelines, it is removed within 5 business days. - Regular audits
We look for unusual patterns – for example several 1-star or 5-star reviews of the same college in a short time, several accounts reviewing a college from the same network, or new accounts reviewing many colleges at once. To spot the same network we keep only a scrambled (hashed) form of the network address, never the address itself, and we delete it after 90 days. Poll results are shown only once at least 25 people have answered.
Quality control keeps changing as we learn from our users, from colleges and from the data itself, and we will keep improving it.
